CEO Performance Evaluation Template

A CEO performance review, also called a CEO performance evaluation, is how a board checks the chief executive’s progress against the goals it agreed with them. Use this template to collect structured feedback on strategy, leadership, results and communication, then agree on priorities for the year ahead.

What is a CEO performance evaluation?

A CEO performance evaluation is a regular, structured review of how the chief executive is doing against goals agreed with the board, usually once a year. It looks at results, and at how the CEO leads: how clearly they set direction, how they build the team, and how they manage the organization’s finances and risks. The same approach works for an executive director or managing director.

A survey makes the review consistent. Everyone answers the same questions, so the board can compare views and see where they agree and where they don’t.

Who should evaluate the CEO?

  • Board members. They hold the CEO accountable and should almost always take part.
  • The CEO. A self-review with the same questions shows where the CEO’s view and the board’s view differ.
  • The leadership team. They see day-to-day leadership and can comment on how decisions are made.
  • Wider staff (optional). This gives a broader view of communication and culture. Decide in advance whether answers are anonymous and how the results will be used.

Decide who takes part before you send the survey, and tell each group how its answers will be used.

CEO performance evaluation questions

1757966728081_456.jpg

Use these 14 questions as a starting point. Respondents rate statements 1 to 12 from strongly disagree to strongly agree, then answer two open questions. Add a first question asking which group they belong to (board, leadership team, CEO or staff), so you can compare answers by group.

Strategy: shows whether the board and the team understand where the organization is going.

  1. The CEO sets a clear direction for the organization.
  2. The CEO turns strategy into priorities that teams understand.
  3. The CEO responds well to changes in our market.

Leadership and team: covers how the CEO builds and supports the people around them.

  1. The CEO builds a strong leadership team.
  2. The CEO creates an environment where people can do their best work.
  3. The CEO gives and accepts honest feedback.

Results and finances: ties the review to the goals and budget agreed with the board.

  1. The CEO manages the organization’s finances responsibly.
  2. The CEO is on track to deliver the goals agreed with the board.
  3. The CEO identifies and manages major risks.

Communication and culture: checks whether the CEO’s message reaches both the board and employees.

  1. The CEO communicates openly with the board.
  2. The CEO communicates clearly with employees.
  3. The CEO’s actions match the organization’s stated values.

Open questions

  1. What is the CEO’s greatest strength?
  2. What one thing should the CEO focus on improving in the next twelve months?

How to run a CEO performance evaluation in Porsline

Step 1: Create the survey. Start from this template and edit the questions so they match the goals agreed with the board.

Step 2: Decide who takes part. Choose the groups and decide whether answers are anonymous. On the Enterprise plan, you can let in only invited board members, by email or code, and keep their identity out of the results.

Step 3: Send the link. Share the survey link by email with each group and set an end date, so the survey closes automatically.

Step 4: Review the results. Compare the answers of the board, the leadership team and the CEO, and look for gaps. Export the results to Excel or CSV on any plan, or use advanced filters on the Enterprise plan.

Step 5: Agree on priorities. Share a summary with the board and the CEO, then choose one to three priorities for the next period. Review progress at your next evaluation.

FAQ: CEO performance evaluation

What should a CEO performance review include?

Most reviews cover four areas: strategy, leadership, results against agreed goals, and communication with the board and staff. Add a self-review by the CEO, and finish with agreed priorities for the next period.

How often should a CEO be evaluated?

Many boards review the CEO once a year, and some add a short check-in halfway through. Choose a rhythm you can keep, and use the same questions each time so you can compare results over time.

Should employees evaluate the CEO?

It depends on your organization. Board members should almost always take part. Including the leadership team or wider staff gives a broader view, but it needs clear rules on anonymity and on how the results will be used.

Can the CEO evaluate themselves?

Yes. A self-review with the same questions shows where the CEO’s view and the board’s view differ, which is a useful starting point for the discussion.

Is this the same as a 360-degree evaluation?

It is similar. A 360-degree evaluation collects feedback from several groups around one person. You can use this template that way by including the board, the leadership team and the CEO’s own view. See our 360-degree feedback survey template.

Is the template free to use?

Yes. You can start on the Free plan, which includes 100 responses a month.

Related forms & survey templates